Tony Benn comes to Stoke Newington in London
Matt Kennard reports from his local area, Stoke Newington, on a political meeting with Tony Benn.
By Matt Kennard on Tuesday, March 3rd, 2009 - 946 words.
Where I live in London has a long history of political radicalism. Social dissidents from Daniel Defoe to Paul Foot to T-Rex frontman Marc Bolan have lived in Stoke Newington over the ages. The working-class roots of the area have been somewhat usurped over the last decade by a more genteel bistro culture for young Guardian-reading parents (Stoke Newington has the highest per capita amount of babies in the UK), but there is still the residue from this rich history of activism, mostly confined to the older generation now, but showing shoots younger down as well. Last night there was something of a renaissance as living legend Tony Benn came to give a lecture on what could be called the Stokey Strip, Church Street. He was speaking alongside three others, two international activists, and President of Stop the War coalition Lindsey German, at Abney Public Hall.
About 250 turned up, a diverse crowd from newsagent owners to teachers to students, to talk about NATO and Afghanistan, although the focus of the discussion leapt about.
First to speak was Haci Ozdemir of the Refugee Workers Quarter Association. “Member states of NATO are at the moment celebrating the sixtieth anniversary of the organization,” he said. “But for workers and for us it should be about condemnation and struggle against NATO… Since April 4th 1949, when it was created, every country occupied by NATO has seen murder and massacre. It was created to encircle the Soviet Union, which was achieved when Greece and Turkey joined in 1951.
“After the disintegration of the Soviet Union the point of it was unclear, but then they attacked Yugoslavia in 1999 to ensure the break up of Yugoslavia into different pieces.”
He went on to talk about 9/11 providing the West with a new enemy and the different machinations of NATO to keep Russia out, and expand into Eastern Europe via Georgia and Ukraine.
The subject of his ire then turned to the Turkish government. “The role of Turkey is crucial,” he said. “Since 1951 they have supported this alliance without qualification. Everyone remembers Israel’s war in Lebanon, well there were Turkish soldiers sent their to be ‘peacekeepers’, and there are 1,300 Turkish soldiers in Afghanistan.”
He also pointed out that a former so-called social democratic Turkish premier is now the governor of NATO in Afghanistan.
According to Ozdemir, NATO has been used in Turkey to combat Kurdish activists, trade unionists, socialists, and other enemies of the state. “NATO troops are supposed to be prepared for foreign invasions, but actually they are used against democrats in Turkey.”
Tony Benn then came on and mentioned that his dad had been born in Kyverdale Road nearby 132 years ago and when his father was 2-years old the British had invaded Afghanistan, but were eventually slung out in 1840 with 1,500 British soldiers dying on the way out.
He recommended Mapsofwar.com, and its feature below:
“The weapons we have now could lead to our extinction,” he said. “If they are used then it is likely the end of humanity. All wars,” he continued, “are about the powerful wanting to steal resources from the weak, in the case of Afghanistan they wanted bases.”
He went on a brief historical lesson then mentioning that from 1914 to 1945 105 million people died in the two world wars. That wasn’t a good record, he thought. “It’s why at 84 I feel like I have to treat young people with respect. My generation cocked it up, but young people seem to understand what is going on.
“They have to keep you frightened,” he went on. “Frightened people don’t ask questions, they just follow orders. It will be China next, there will be a MI5 man in every Chinese takeaway, you can trust me on that.”
On his journey through 20th century history, Benn next talked about Hiroshima and Nagasaki. “The interesting thing about the Cold War is that it began before the end of the last war. The atomic bombs dropped in Japan were the first blow in the Cold War. I went to Hiroshima and they took me around. They pointed out a mark on the curb. I asked why they pointed it out, and they said a child had been sitting there when the bomb literally vaporized them, there was a metal lunchbox next to it; it vaporized the child, but couldn’t destroy the lunchbox.
“When I went to Japan, I came to understand that the Japanese had offered to surrender before the bombs were dropped.”
He finished by saying he’s an optimist — “You have to be at my age!” — and said that everyone should ask three questions when presented with a political issue: 1. What’s going on here? 2. Why is it going on? And 3. What do you do about it? “That’s hard to do with our media,” he conceded, “but you can try!”
Finally, Gan Majicek, from the No Bases Initiative in Czech Republic spoke out. “We formed in 2006,” she said, “and started organizing against the agenda of our government and its mission to put bases in our country. They spent $500,000 on a propaganda campaign as to why we need these bases, but still polls show 65-70 percent of Czechs are against the Radar bases.”
She said the argument is that they need Radar to stop attacks from Iran or Germany. But then mentioned that the scientific community has pointed out how missile defense systems are just not practical because they can be derailed by decoys very easily.
Down the road, the brilliant author Iain Sinclair was discussing his new book about his wanderings around Hackney — which is the borough that Stoke Newington sits in. Despite the gentrification and the genericification of Stokey, something is growing here.
(+2 rating, 2 votes)
Loading ...4 Comments
Leave a Reply
Matt Kennard
26London
Matt Kennard graduated from the Journalism School at Columbia University as a Toni Stabile Investigative scholar in 2008. He now works for the Financial Times in London. He has written for the Guardian, Salon, The Comment Factory and the Chicago Tribune, amongst others. In 2006 he won the Guardian Student Feature Writer of the Year Award
mattkennard@thecommentfactory.com
Articles by this author
-
Chavez, Morales and Correa must speak out on Iran
As I said some months ago, when I get depressed about the state of the world I’m always cheered to think of the movements in Latin America that are genuinely empowering the hitherto marginalised sections of those societies. This movement has the power to make itself felt throughout the world – but it needs to apply itself consistently. That can even take the approach of Lula who stopped short of denunciation and just put forward an offer of sanctuary in an effort to shame the Iranian regime
-
The Observer's Chomsky fetish
Chomsky is big enough to put up with this kind of rubbish, but can the Guardian or Observer, the most influential left-wing journal in the English-speaking world, really not find one journalist who doesn’t have a visceral dislike of Noam Chomsky? Sadly, but maybe predictably, for a newspaper made up of liberals pickled in the self-righteous playfields of Oxbridge liberalism, I guess they don’t
-
The fight to preserve Latin America's democratic revolution
For Prof Anderson the template of Spain after Franco’s destruction of civil society “has become the general formula of freedom: no longer making the world safe for democracy, but democracy safe for this world.” Through a confluence of historical factors, Latin America is the crucible where the last chance to make a world safe for democracy is being fought. The importance of this battle shouldn’t be underestimated: if it fails, we might not get another chance
-
Jan Nederveen Pieterse on Globalization and Empire
The fundamentals of American weakness are its shrinking share of world manufacturing, its gargantuan consumption, low savings rate, faulty policies (massive military spending, massive war spending, deep tax cuts) and gigantic financial deficits. Some problems are structural (high American health care costs are a function of lack of restraint on pharmaceutical industries and reflect the large influence of business interests); this prompts outsourcing, which further weakens the American economy. The military interventions are destabilizing (increase risks for others) and costly (adding to American economic problems) and erode American legitimacy. So the problems are not merely overstretch
-
Massive Attack on influences, war and the cult of fame
I think a lot of it is damaging and I feel there has to be at some point a change in the way we deal with different peoples situations and development. I hate double standards more than anything – I hate the current row over Iran’s nuclear ambitions and whether they should be allowed to have nuclear technology or even nuclear energy. It seems to me that our history is littered with hypocrisy and I find that quite hard to live with being a British citizen
-
Matt Kennard on Russia Today extended: 'US Army sent 'hardcore' neo-Nazi troops to Iraq and Afghanistan'
Under the Bush administration, the U.S. military allegedly started to recruit neo-Nazis and gang members to fight in Afghanistan and Iraq. Investigative journalist Matt Kennard talks to RT about his researh into these allegations and other problems in the US military.
-
Tony Benn on the EU, Cuba and Islam
Well I don’t think it helps to go around saying, “Try Blair for war crimes,” if you’re trying to persuade Labour MPs to vote against the war and they are told they’ve got to arrest and see Blair and Cherie locked up. It’s ridiculous. I said this to all the people… I mean it’s mad… I can understand peoples anger, but it is crazy
-
Hilary Benn on aid, the US, Iraq, and Tony Blair
The truth is: The real answer to the question why did we take the decision that we did, is because on the 18th March 2003 a majority of the House of Commons voted to do it
-
Johann Hari on Chomsky, Hitchens, Iraq, and anarchism
But I think Hitchens arguments are so well put and one should engage with them and take them at face value. He says Saddam was intermeshed increasingly with Islam. Zarquawi, for example, was already in Iraq before the war. I don’t agree with his argument on that. Ba’athism and Islamism are different things, and should be opposed for different reasons
-
Polly Toynbee on Iraq and New Labour
No I think it’s very difficult to navigate because for one thing even if you more want to bring democracy to the Middle East more than you want to take the oil – which I think probably is the case now – but such is the fear of fundamentalism that you wonder if you knock over the Saudi’s who takes over? Is it even stronger Wahhabist, and is that even more dangerous, and even less democratic? It’s very difficult
-
Noam Chomsky on the US Empire and hopes and prospects
They hope that China will organize a coalition of peace loving states to stop the militarism and aggressiveness headed by the US and its British ally. Well it's interesting that they have such contempt for American democracy and British democracy: they don't even dream of it coming from within. I don't agree with it - I don't think we have to wait for China to save us from all doom - I think we can do it ourselves
-
Professor Michael Mann on America's incoherent empire
The most you can have is a kind of informal imperialism where the state remains sovereign - you don’t try to interfere in it but you limit its options. This is what, typically, the US has done in Latin America when it is not intervening. The US is formidable. People contrast so-called multilateralism to unilateralist and they think of the United Nations. The US runs the UN and had run the UN for most of the 1990s and that’s what the US can do because the US provides certain resources that no-one else can provide. Nothing much is going to happen in the way of international activity unless the US is part of it and leading it and that’s what the US can return to again. What I think it cannot do is to reconstruct foreign countries on its own without having considerable local support
Thanks for putting up the map.
'Hey mate fancy a pint on the Stokey Strip?'. Kennels that is banter. The Stokey Strip indeed, I'll be dining out on that one for a while (no pun intended). In all seriousness do you really reckon something is brewing in Stoke Newington? What exactly? Is it not the same old middle-class objectioning over a frothy latte, and the last residues of its activist history (as you point out)? I've never seen much different to be honest, apart from the Turkish political presence (PKK etc.). Also, if we're talking Stokey leftist history you have to mention The Angry Brigade!
Darling, we'll have you yoghurt weavers for tea here in Sarf London. And you know it.
We are the scum you purport to support x
You reposted a map which helps contextualise arguments you hear out of the New Left. You boast of what the erudite of N16 get up to on a Friday night. You wipe your hands. You zip your fly. You open the door of your Victorian semi, replay Channel 4 News, skim thru the Guardian, make a note of a demo at the weekend.
You've changed nothing. You've challenged no one. In the words of Jarvis Cocker "cunts are still running the world".
What is this? Social masturbation disguised as political anger?