Friday, Sep 3rd, 2010

Britain’s education system needs to learn how to nurture not just instruct

After working in the British education system for a short spell I believe that it’s priorities are all mixed up.

By Sally Omar on Sunday, February 8th, 2009 - 985 words.

Share

kidsabuWhen I was a kid my dad used to tell me that the devil eats with his left hand. Even though I was born left-handed my dad would stop me whenever I tried to use my natural hand to write or draw, not out of malicious intent but because in his culture it was frowned upon – the left hand was apparently dirty and impure.

As I grew up I came to understand why he had done this, but I was and still am angry that my nature was distorted without my consent (I now write with my right-hand). I value my fathers traditions, but I now think that in a lot of ways the switch in my writing hand has played an integral role in my personality development.

It was with some surprise then that since I have arrived in London and started working with children with so-called “learning disabilities” I have realized that there was something in what my dad said. Not in a religious sense, but there is undoubtedly a correlation between kids who are left-handed and have some kind of learning setback. I was fascinated to learn that three out of the four children I work with are left-handed.

But like I was maligned for left-handed, while living in London I have had a journey into the British education system, and I am coming to terms with the fact that here huge numbers of children who are left behind because of similar abuse. And this realization has come with a feeling of outrage. The children I work with have been called “slow”, “disabled”, “less capable”, or just a “lost cause” that will never excel at anything. Fellow teachers say things like, “There’s something really wrong with that kid, isn’t there?” But having spent two months with these children I have the exact opposite feeling.

Without putting each child’s story out in the public domain, I am confident in thinking that their behaviors and so-called disabilities are on whole a result of hindrance in their early development. Our parents are undoubtedly the strongest indication of how we will turn out. Trust me, like most people my age I have fought the reality of this situation, but it is inescapeable. My father with every good intention genuinely wanted me to write with a hand that the devil did not eat with. And as silly as it may sound I do understand.

I have another contention with the method of teaching here. I think creating a relationship of fear between the teacher and student has worked sometimes, but that ignores the kids that don’t need to be told off, but need and want actual emotional support, like I needed. A lot of children are continuously told they will never be good enough so they finally give up. What would a little bit of support do?

In Britain, they expect children to leave their shit at the door and come to school regardless of all their home problems – getting beat, sexually abused, or completely neglected. I understand that school is meant to be a place of learning, but it is also one of the only places kids have away from home and if children come knowing the support they need can’t be found there, than we lose a huge group of amazing minds that succumb to a lack of stimulus and emotional warmth.

To make this more personal I know that if I was not supported emotionally by my parents throughout my education I would be nowhere. I got an abnormally low score on my SAT’s, had a fairly decent GPA, but the only reason I got into the University of California, Los Angeles was because I was privileged enough to have been dancing since I was six and auditioned to get into one of the best dance programs around. Now, if I had listened to the reasons why someone like me couldn’t and probably shouldn’t get in, I would have been one of the many others that got lost along the way, beaten down by fear and lack of confidence.

So I must tell you the honest truth: this really has nothing and everything to do with being left-handed. Yes, in my small sample of children that have learning disabilities, three out of four are left handed, and in my experience my development was stunted by dogmatism. But what I have learnt in the British education system is more to do with all types of learners, and the absolute necessity of aiding kids in their emotional development of children and human beings in general.

I freely admit that most of my problems and insecurities happened at a very young age because as an abnormally sensitive six year old I took everything to heart. Being placed back in an elementary/primary school setting as a 22-year old adult I realize how much closer I am mentally to these nine year olds than I am to my peers. Unfortunately, these kids are going to travel through their education without me holding their hand.

I have struggled the past few weeks with this realization, because I am not one to give up even when the politics of the situation would seem to suggest that route. But at the end of the day this is a human rights issue, one that is bigger than even me and I am realizing that whether nine years old or 22, we all yearn for a sense of belonging and a feeling of love from those around us. I found a feeling of belonging with these children and I can only selfishly hope they have felt the same way with me. At this point in my life I can’t change a system that was established before I was switched from left to right, but I hope that talking to these children as an equal has given them hope at a future that involves something bigger than feeling alone and different.

Disagree with this articleAgree with this article (+1 rating, 1 votes)
Loading ... Loading ...

This website uses IntenseDebate comments, but they are not currently loaded because either your browser doesn't support JavaScript, or they didn't load fast enough.

10 Comments

  1. MartinDyan says:

    Sally! Great to see that you're a) in London and b) writing for the Comment Facory (as if you had any choice! heh). I have the poor feeling throughout this article that left-handers generally have a 'learning setback' or are you referring to the disabled kids you work with specifically? Let's not forget that Barack Obama is left handed!____Also, i'm afraid i disagree with your statement "In Britain, they expect children to leave their shit at the door and come to school regardless of all their home problems – getting beat, sexually abused, or completely neglected". Even though the state of some schools across the UK is terrible including constant truancy and poor supplies, a number of schools have teachers who act as private mentors in a social work type capacity. From my own experience my teachers were concerned about my well-being and the fact that i embraced a diverse range of activities

  2. MartinDyan says:

    Sally! Great to see that you're a) in London and b) writing for the Comment Facory (as if you had any choice! heh). I have the poor feeling throughout this article that left-handers generally have a 'learning setback' or are you referring to the disabled kids you work with specifically? Let's not forget that Barack Obama is left handed!

    Also, i'm afraid i disagree with your statement "In Britain, they expect children to leave their shit at the door and come to school regardless of all their home problems – getting beat, sexually abused, or completely neglected". Even though the state of some schools across the UK is terrible including constant truancy and poor supplies, a number of schools have teachers who act as private mentors in a social work type capacity. From my own experience my teachers were concerned about my well-being and the fact that i embraced a diverse range of activities; perhaps this could be a solution to those who have issues at home – to encourage them to participate in activies away from home to act as "stimulus and emotional warmth" as you correctly put it.

    Having said all that, I never knew how you did get into UCLA and will always remember how you taught me to wave – sik!

    M

    • Sally Omar says:

      I see what you mean and thinking about the article today I never intended for it to come off so harsh. I really am not talking about the teachers because all the teachers I specifically work with are incredible. I think the lack of training in Psychology and just Child Development in general is more what I am referring to. And in an earlier version of my article I mentioned that Barack Obama is left handed as a good thing. Matt can testify to the fact that I was first to be super stoked about this.
      I did not really intend to make an attack on the British school systems but just education in general. Just the other day I was speaking to a friend who mentioned that her brother loved school up until one teacher decided to pick on him endlessly. So I am just mentioning the people that don't realize, either by accident or because they could care less, that they have forever affected the future and self confidence of a child. If I could be more specific about my exact expereince I would be able to justify better.

      • Sally Omar says:

        cont:
        I also want to be clear that I absolutly adore left handed people and still to this day wish I was. Left handed poeple do not have learning disabilities. My only claim was that maybe they were different learners because I know I am. And I also know that with the visual stimulation I have tried to offer these children and with changes at home they have flourished and developed at such a rapid pace that the entire staff is shocked.
        So please do not be mislead as I am very aware of the support teachers give.
        So that is that. And thank you so much for bringing it up because I was worried it may be misread.

        I hope you are well!! What are u up to anyway??

        • MartinDyan says:

          Cool, well thanks for explaining. I think what you're doing is awesome by the way. If you're helping children to develop, whether disabled or not, it is something to be proud of.

          I'm working in London and following thecommentfactory!

          • Jordan Pearson says:

            I'm not sure about the statement that the "devil eats with his left hand", but after walking in on Dyan in the bathroom one time, I can confirm that the devil "beats with his left hand"….

          • MartinDyan says:

            How many times Jordy, I was trying to get the toothpaste out of the tube…

  3. Julian says:

    I was surprised by your experience with left handedness. I have no expertise in this area, but everything I've ever read suggests that left handedness correlates with higher intelligence. For example: http://www.independent.co.uk/life-style/health-an...

    Of course, averages don't necessarily mean much to the individual.

  4. Sally says:

    Really interesting article. Thanks Julian!

  5. Anna says:

    This information is excellent and very informative.

Leave a Reply

Sally Omar





Articles by this author
Search the site